hashcat 2.01 vs 3.1
#1
Hi this test ran on the same machine I've different performance btw old hscat and new one. Someone else had the problem ????

VERSION 2.01
Hashtype: MD4
Workload: 1024 loops, 256 accel
Speed.GPU.#1.: 3907.0 MH/s

Hashtype: MD5
Workload: 1024 loops, 256 accel
Speed.GPU.#1.: 2785.2 MH/s

Hashtype: Half MD5
Workload: 1024 loops, 256 accel
Speed.GPU.#1.: 824.2 MH/s

Hashtype: SHA1
Workload: 1024 loops, 256 accel
Speed.GPU.#1.: 649.5 MH/s

Hashtype: SHA256
Workload: 1024 loops, 256 accel
Speed.GPU.#1.: 303.8 MH/s

Hashtype: SHA384
Workload: 256 loops, 256 accel
Speed.GPU.#1.: 76994.9 kH/s

Hashtype: SHA512
Workload: 256 loops, 256 accel
Speed.GPU.#1.: 76958.6 kH/s

Hashtype: SHA-3(Keccak)
Workload: 128 loops, 256 accel
Speed.GPU.#1.: 46884.0 kH/s

Speed.GPU.#1.: 3452.8 MH/s
Hashtype: RipeMD160
Workload: 1024 loops, 256 accel

ERROR: Temperature limit on GPU 1 reached, aborting...
Speed.GPU.#1.: 553.8 MH/s
Hashtype: Whirlpool
Workload: 512 loops, 32 accel
Speed.GPU.#1.: 46703.3 kH/s

Hashtype: GOST R 34.11-94
Workload: 512 loops, 64 accel
Speed.GPU.#1.: 44633.3 kH/s

Hashtype: GOST R 34.11-2012 (Streebog) 256-bit
Workload: 512 loops, 16 accel
Speed.GPU.#1.: 10419.1 kH/s

Hashtype: GOST R 34.11-2012 (Streebog) 512-bit
Workload: 512 loops, 16 accel
Speed.GPU.#1.: 10397.2 kH/s

Hashtype: phpass, MD5(Wordpress), MD5(phpBB3), MD5(Joomla)
Workload: 1024 loops, 32 accel
Speed.GPU.#1.: 671.0 kH/s

Hashtype: scrypt
Workload: 1 loops, 64 accel
Speed.GPU.#1.: 19619 H/s

Hashtype: PBKDF2-HMAC-MD5
Workload: 1000 loops, 8 accel
Speed.GPU.#1.: 675.6 kH/s

Speed.GPU.#1.: 335.9 kH/s

Hashtype: PBKDF2-HMAC-SHA256
Workload: 1000 loops, 8 accel
Speed.GPU.#1.: 120.5 kH/s

Hashtype: PBKDF2-HMAC-SHA512
Workload: 1000 loops, 8 accel
Speed.GPU.#1.: 33919 H/s

Hashtype: Skype
Workload: 1024 loops, 256 accel
Speed.GPU.#1.: 503.5 MH/s

Hashtype: WPA/WPA2
Workload: 1024 loops, 32 accel



VERSION 3.1
Hashtype: MD4

Speed.Dev.#1.: 188.6 MH/s (95.71ms)
Speed.Dev.#3.: 2423.0 MH/s (98.90ms)
Speed.Dev.#*.: 2611.6 MH/s

Hashtype: MD5

Speed.Dev.#1.: 114.3 MH/s (94.30ms)
Speed.Dev.#3.: 1701.1 MH/s (98.37ms)
Speed.Dev.#*.: 1815.4 MH/s

Hashtype: Half MD5

Speed.Dev.#1.: 73634.3 kH/s (94.52ms)
Speed.Dev.#3.: 1186.4 MH/s (97.38ms)
Speed.Dev.#*.: 1260.0 MH/s

Hashtype: SHA1

Speed.Dev.#1.: 43962.6 kH/s (93.16ms)
Speed.Dev.#3.: 446.7 MH/s (97.78ms)
Speed.Dev.#*.: 490.6 MH/s

Hashtype: SHA256

Speed.Dev.#1.: 16643.5 kH/s (92.87ms)
Speed.Dev.#3.: 180.4 MH/s (98.50ms)
Speed.Dev.#*.: 197.0 MH/s

Hashtype: SHA384

Speed.Dev.#1.: 5095.0 kH/s (89.75ms)
Speed.Dev.#3.: 63572.8 kH/s (95.08ms)
Speed.Dev.#*.: 68667.8 kH/s

Hashtype: SHA512

Speed.Dev.#1.: 5096.4 kH/s (89.75ms)
Speed.Dev.#3.: 66392.7 kH/s (93.56ms)
Speed.Dev.#*.: 71489.0 kH/s

Hashtype: SHA-3(Keccak)

Speed.Dev.#1.: 517.3 kH/s (78.49ms)
Speed.Dev.#3.: 53991.9 kH/s (67.64ms)
Speed.Dev.#*.: 54509.2 kH/s

Hashtype: SipHash

Speed.Dev.#1.: 182.1 MH/s (97.67ms)
Speed.Dev.#3.: 2667.4 MH/s (98.66ms)
Speed.Dev.#*.: 2849.5 MH/s

Hashtype: RipeMD160

Speed.Dev.#1.: 24536.0 kH/s (94.49ms)
Speed.Dev.#3.: 295.7 MH/s (98.96ms)
Speed.Dev.#*.: 320.2 MH/s

Hashtype: Whirlpool

Speed.Dev.#1.: 511.0 kH/s (79.43ms)
Speed.Dev.#3.: 38987.0 kH/s (182.37ms)
Speed.Dev.#*.: 39498.0 kH/s

Hashtype: GOST R 34.11-94

Speed.Dev.#1.: 3135.2 kH/s (155.89ms)
Speed.Dev.#3.: 43323.2 kH/s (158.51ms)
Speed.Dev.#*.: 46458.4 kH/s

Hashtype: GOST R 34.11-2012 (Streebog) 256-bit

Speed.Dev.#1.: 867.5 kH/s (176.21ms)
Speed.Dev.#3.: 9307.9 kH/s (226.08ms)
Speed.Dev.#*.: 10175.4 kH/s

Hashtype: GOST R 34.11-2012 (Streebog) 512-bit

Speed.Dev.#1.: 867.7 kH/s (176.11ms)
Speed.Dev.#3.: 9380.3 kH/s (219.73ms)
Speed.Dev.#*.: 10248.1 kH/s

Hashtype: phpass, MD5(Wordpress), MD5(phpBB3), MD5(Joomla)

Speed.Dev.#1.: 34067 H/s (94.25ms)
Speed.Dev.#3.: 474.2 kH/s (87.82ms)
Speed.Dev.#*.: 508.3 kH/s

Hashtype: scrypt

Speed.Dev.#1.: 14329 H/s (85.11ms)
Speed.Dev.#3.: 38337 H/s (91.88ms)
Speed.Dev.#*.: 52666 H/s

Hashtype: PBKDF2-HMAC-MD5

Speed.Dev.#1.: 35723 H/s (94.83ms)
Speed.Dev.#3.: 483.9 kH/s (86.11ms)
Speed.Dev.#*.: 519.7 kH/s

Hashtype: PBKDF2-HMAC-SHA1

Speed.Dev.#1.: 17118 H/s (94.03ms)
Speed.Dev.#3.: 183.7 kH/s (105.01ms)
Speed.Dev.#*.: 200.9 kH/s

Hashtype: PBKDF2-HMAC-SHA256

Speed.Dev.#1.: 6751 H/s (92.79ms)
Speed.Dev.#3.: 78650 H/s (91.73ms)
Speed.Dev.#*.: 85400 H/s

Hashtype: PBKDF2-HMAC-SHA512

Speed.Dev.#1.: 2418 H/s (99.38ms)
Speed.Dev.#3.: 31800 H/s (94.50ms)
Speed.Dev.#*.: 34218 H/s

Hashtype: Skype

Speed.Dev.#1.: 72038.9 kH/s (94.83ms)
Speed.Dev.#3.: 998.3 MH/s (98.53ms)
Speed.Dev.#*.: 1070.4 MH/s

Hashtype: WPA/WPA2

Speed.Dev.#1.: 2048 H/s (91.03ms)
Speed.Dev.#3.: 25048 H/s (96.20ms)
Speed.Dev.#*.: 27096 H/s
Reply
#2
In your first test you only have one device, in your second test you have at least 3 devices (though you've skipped #2). Is this really an apples-to-apples comparison you're doing? Also, have you tried benchmarking without the CPU?
Reply
#3
Thanks for the high quality post, not exactly pointing out something in particular, nor giving any detail like hardware, driver version or the like.

If you're just trying to point out speed differences between two major versions of hashcat, yes, we are kind of aware of that, it may have been tracked since some time already.

It may even be on a spreadsheet like this one
Reply
#4
Well thank you for the replay:

Well i've disabled the integrated intel HD that in previous post was enabled.

I don't know how to benchmark without the CPU can you help me?

I've tried again with HS VERSION 2.01 --> same result as previous post
Ive tried again with HS VERSION 3.1 --> benchmark still behind
OpenCL Platform #1: Intel(R) Corporation
========================================
- Device #1: Intel(R) Core(TM) i7-4702HQ CPU @ 2.20GHz, skipped
OpenCL Platform #2: NVIDIA Corporation GTX 870m
======================================

Hashtype: MD4
Speed.Dev.#2.: 2496.5 MH/s (96.11ms)

Hashtype: MD5
Speed.Dev.#2.: 1745.7 MH/s (95.78ms)

Hashtype: Half MD5
Speed.Dev.#2.: 1218.6 MH/s (95.54ms)

Hashtype: SHA1
Speed.Dev.#2.: 455.7 MH/s (95.32ms)

Hashtype: SHA256
Speed.Dev.#2.: 185.6 MH/s (95.86ms)

Hashtype: SHA384
Speed.Dev.#2.: 63606.3 kH/s (94.70ms)

Hashtype: SHA512
Speed.Dev.#2.: 65429.5 kH/s (96.50ms)

Hashtype: SHA-3(Keccak)
Speed.Dev.#2.: 56253.0 kH/s (65.10ms)

Hashtype: SipHash
Speed.Dev.#2.: 2753.7 MH/s (95.82ms)

Hashtype: RipeMD160
Speed.Dev.#2.: 300.2 MH/s (97.45ms)

Hashtype: Whirlpool
Speed.Dev.#2.: 39699.8 kH/s (179.24ms)

Hashtype: GOST R 34.11-94
Speed.Dev.#2.: 44529.8 kH/s (155.27ms)

Hashtype: GOST R 34.11-2012 (Streebog) 256-bit
Speed.Dev.#2.: 9118.1 kH/s (230.94ms)

Hashtype: GOST R 34.11-2012 (Streebog) 512-bit
Speed.Dev.#2.: 9519.9 kH/s (221.21ms)

Hashtype: phpass, MD5(Wordpress), MD5(phpBB3), MD5(Joomla)
Speed.Dev.#2.: 474.0 kH/s (88.34ms)

Hashtype: scrypt
Speed.Dev.#2.: 38544 H/s (91.91ms)

Hashtype: PBKDF2-HMAC-MD5
Speed.Dev.#2.: 490.9 kH/s (85.17ms)

Hashtype: PBKDF2-HMAC-SHA1
Speed.Dev.#2.: 190.0 kH/s (102.18ms)

Hashtype: PBKDF2-HMAC-SHA256
Speed.Dev.#2.: 79256 H/s (91.29ms)

Hashtype: PBKDF2-HMAC-SHA512
Speed.Dev.#2.: 31594 H/s (91.36ms)

Hashtype: Skype
Speed.Dev.#2.: 1027.0 MH/s (95.87ms)

Hashtype: WPA/WPA2
Speed.Dev.#2.: 24237 H/s (97.54ms)

Hashtype: IKE-PSK MD5
Speed.Dev.#2.: 135.0 MH/s (95.03ms)

Well i did't think was relevant but is a windows 10 laptop with nvidia card an intel integrated that's it
Reply
#5
You can try with --opencl-vector-width 1 or 2 or 4, see if it changes anything
Reply
#6
(11-09-2016, 11:31 PM)atom Wrote: You can try with --opencl-vector-width 1 or 2 or 4, see if it changes anything

Thank you for the help,
I tried: it slightly changes the benchmark (the best with option 1 followed by option 4 and than 2) but I achieve better performance with the old distro
Reply